How Often Should Human Resource Strategies Be Evaluated?

Frequently reviewing human resource strategies is a good practice. Evaluating these policies and procedures regularly is important to maintain sustainability and enhance staff morale. But how often should small businesses access their HR strategies?

In this guide, we’ll look at how often HR strategy evaluations should be done, the best practices for conducting a review, and the ways they can greatly contribute to the overall success of your business goals.

When Should I Schedule an HR Evaluation?

Most companies should carry out an all-around HR evaluation every 12 months. However, other external changes or company milestones may require shorter intervals between appraisals. For example:

  • Regulatory changes: Legislative updates affecting employment law, benefits, and workplace safety can dramatically alter the landscape. For example, additional reviews should be conducted to ensure that you remain compliant with any recent government legislation.
  • Market dynamics: Changes in standard pay packages due to increased availability of talent within your industry’s labor market may mean it’s time for another review for your HR team. Moreover, this allows you to attract and retain qualified staff members, significantly enhancing competitiveness.
  • Business growth or downsizing: Large-scale shifts in size within organizations, like expansions or retractions, call for reconsidering current human resource systems.
  • Technological advancements: The introduction of new HR technologies or data management systems presents an opportunity for evaluation. Additionally, consider having mini-reviews or check-ins on particular HR domains, like retention initiatives or talent management, more frequently.

What Are the Best Human Resources Evaluation Methods?

For any business—be it small-scale or large-scale—the quality of its human resources can either make or break it. Consequentially, evaluating HR policies and procedures goes beyond compliance and becomes an issue of strategic necessity.

This involves employing methods such as auditing (especially one carried out by independent consultants) and performance indicators. Audits allow a detailed review of compliance processes, policies, and procedures, while performance metrics constantly reflect HR contributions to business objectives.

This two-way approach establishes adherence to best practices and connects strategic human resource management to broader corporate goals, enhancing competitiveness and providing an encouraging working milieu. Here’s how they offer a mirror to your effectiveness:

Conducting An HR Audit 

  • Planning: Define the scope and objectives of your audit clearly. This is a great way to evaluate its HR function in specific components such as recruitment, payroll, or performance management.
  • Data collection: Gather any documents that might be useful, like policies, guidelines, and records that reflect performance. Check and include everything from employee manuals to disciplinary records.
  • Analysis: This means going deep into the information that has been collected so far. Consequently, it seeks to identify areas of non-compliance and inefficiency. The aim is to compare your practices with those in the industry to bridge the gaps.
  • Reporting: The result will be a detailed report containing findings and advice on what steps should be taken by human resource managers or business owners to improve their functions accordingly.
  • Implementation and follow-up: Putting ideas into action can be part of the audit process. So can measuring the results to provide insights into the correct next moves.

Essential HR Metrics to Track

  • Turnover rates: This shows the number of employees who quit working for a company, which can guide the creation of measures that increase employee loyalty and satisfaction.
  • Employee engagement:  Employee surveys that are conducted by companies in order to determine how much employees enjoy their work.
  • Training ROI: It’s possible to learn whether training programs are effective or not, by tracking where employees have improved their skills or competencies.
  • Time-to-Hire: An efficiency metric that reflects the agility of your recruiting process, impacting your ability to attract top talent quickly.

What HR Initiatives, Projects, and Areas Should Be Evaluated?


The recruitment process is the foundation of any strong HR strategy. It determines the quality and fit of new hires. Job advertisements, sourcing strategies, and selection methods must be continuously monitored to ensure that only high-potential employees are brought on board.

Areas of evaluation

  • Efficiency and effectiveness of the recruitment cycle
  • Diversity and inclusivity in hiring practices
  • Candidate experience throughout the hiring process

Payroll Processes

Managing payroll isn’t about ensuring employees’ salary payments are done on time. That would be easy! It involves complex issues such as tax compliance, deductions, employee benefits administration, and record keeping.

Areas of evaluation

  • Accuracy and timeliness of payroll execution
  • Compliance with local, state, and federal tax laws
  • Integration with other HR systems for seamless data flow

Record Collection and Management

HR departments handle loads of confidential information, such as employee addresses or employee performance assessments. These details must be properly managed in line with confidentiality requirements and any data protection legislation in place.

Areas of evaluation

  • Security measures to protect employee data
  • Accessibility and accuracy of records
  • Compliance with GDPR or other relevant data protection legislation

Employee Engagement and Satisfaction

Employees who are engaged in their work tend to be more productive, have greater satisfaction at their jobs, and rarely leave. In fact, according to a study, highly engaged employees are 87% less likely to leave their jobs. Evaluating the level of employee engagement regularly can help identify shortcomings in the work environment, company culture, or management system.

Areas for evaluation

  • Staff feedback through surveys and other channels
  • Reasons for leaving and employee turnover
  • Engagement initiatives and their impact on the business

Get Help Evaluating Your Human Resources Strategies

Every single function in HR —be it recruitment, payroll processes, onboarding, HRM, records keeping, staffing, employee development, or engagement strategies—plays a critical role in determining how successful an organization turns out to be.

Routine evaluation of these areas—which include recruitment policies, payroll processing, records management systems (centralized versus decentralized filing systems), staff training and development, SWOT analysis, and retention strategies, among others—guarantees that your company stays compliant and has a competitive edge. All while taking the lead in terms of employee satisfaction and productivity.

But knowing where to start, what to evaluate, and how to implement the necessary changes may be difficult. For such reasons, JSD Consulting comes in handy. By using our expertise in evaluating strategic HR plans or helping you formulate one, we can give you insights on how best you can improve your HR practices, driving forward your business. Contact JSD Consulting today!